Silent Spring at 50

The False Crises of Rachel Carson

Widely credited with launching the modern environmental movement when published 50 years ago, Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring had a profound impact on our society. As an iconic work, the book has often been shielded from critical inquiry, but this landmark anniversary provides an excellent opportunity to reassess its legacy and influence. In Silent Spring at 50: The False Crises of Rachel Carson a team of national experts explores the book’s historical context, the science it was built on, and the policy consequences of its core ideas. The conclusion makes it abundantly clear that the legacy of Silent Spring is highly problematic. While the book provided some clear benefits, a number of Carson’s major arguments rested on what can only be described as deliberate ignorance. Despite her reputation as a careful writer widely praised for building her arguments on science and facts, Carson’s best-seller contained significant errors and sins of omission. Much of what was presented as certainty then was slanted, and today we know much of it is simply wrong.
 
 
Praise for Silent Spring at 50:
 
"A powerful collection that offers new insights on Carson's epoch-making book and challenges its scientific underpinnings and purpose. This book should stir even the most committed Carson enthusiast to reassess Silent Spring's much celebrated status. A must read for those who thake the environment seriously."
- Bruce Yandle, Dean Emeritus, College of Business and behavioral Science, Clemson University
 
"This book offers a much needed perspective on one of the most misguided and overpraised books of the 20th century. However noble her intentions, in Silent Spring, Rachel Carson provided the impetus for a half-century of environmental policies that have cost hundreds of millions of lives and elicited antagonism toward many products and technologies that could have benefited the planet and its inhabitants."
- Henry Miller, Robert Wesson Fellow in Scientific Philosophy and Public Policy, Hoover Institution, Stanford University
 
"Silent Spring sent environmental policy down the road of more and more federal regulation. The authors in this book review Rachel Carson's data and conclusions and find that both are flawed. By reading this book and giving it to your favorite politician and environmentalist friends, you will help create a better environment and enhance individual freedom."
- Terry L. Anderson, President, Property and Environment Research Center and Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution
 
"Rather than paying tribute to Rachel Carson's manifesto Silent Spring at 50 pays her work the compliment of expecting and demanding that it stand up to empirical and theoretical doubts. My respect for Carson's legacy has now been informed, tested, and refined by authors who treated Carson as the scientist she sought to be."
- Heidi M. Hurd, Director of the Program in Law and Philosophy, University of Illinois.

"Silent Spring at 50 brings together a brilliant collection of scholars to evaluate this founding text of modern environmentalism. Five decades after its publication they show that Rachel Carson got a lot of her science wrong and that her passionate advocacy may have resulted in more harm than good."
- Ron Bailey, Science Correspondent, Reason
Type: 
  An economist and lawyer, Roger Meiners defends the superiority of the common law--legal traditions developed through the courts--over federal regulation. In his view, the success of markets is intertwined with the common laws strong protection for property rights. Common law protects the environment by allowing individuals to take action...
Read More > More Articles by Roger Meiners >
Pierre Desrochers is an associate professor of geography at the University of Toronto and a 2009 PERC Julian Simon Fellow. He can be reached at pierre.desrochers@utoronto.ca.
Read More > More Articles by Pierre Desrochers >
Andrew Morriss is the author or coauthor of more than 50 scholarly articles, books, and book chapters. He serves as a Research Fellow at the New York University Center for Labor and Employment Law, a Senior Fellow at the Property & Environment Research Center in Bozeman, Montana, and a Senior Scholar at the Mercatus Center at George Mason...
Read More > More Articles by Andrew Morriss >