Earth Hour: To See or Not to See?

Posted by: 

Last Saturday night (March 26) was Earth Hour. A time that, presumably, billions of people turn out their lights to support energy conservation. Hilton Worldwide, among other hotels and businesses, claim to participate in this celebration.

In its fifth year, Earth Hour was designed for people to show their support for sustainable actions. How could anybody oppose such a simple act or environmental sustainability itself?

Often there is more than meets the eye. That is my impetus to blog; not to dwell on what is seen, rather to point out what is often not seen, as so eloquently described by Frederic Bastiat more than 100 years ago.

Rather than reiterate here what others have already said, I will merely redirect you to their points.

  • Ross McKitrick “abhors” Earth Hour because it demonizes electricity regardless of the benefits and increased prosperity that it provides.
  • Don Boudreaux and others celebrate Human Achievement hour instead, and propose turning the lights on.
  • Krishnan comments that resource use is often mistaken for waste even when it provides for increased well-being.
While many across the globe see more clearly with the lights on, the costs of energy and resource use are often emphasized more than the benefits. Benefits from energy use include increased prosperity, health, leisure, and education, even enhanced environmental quality. I commend resource conservation when it is efficient to do so. But a goal to merely reduce resource use is myopic.

As an interesting sideline, I stayed in a Hilton brand hotel in Montana this weekend and heard nary a word about Earth Hour.

Originally posted at Environmental Trends

Holly Fretwell is a Research Fellow at PERC and an adjunct instructor at Montana State University where she has taught  introductory economics, macroeconomics, natural resources and environmental economics. She works with the Foundation for Teaching Economics, giving workshops for  high school teachers to improve their skills in teaching and...
Read More > More Articles by Holly Fretwell >