Skip to content

About PERC

All Areas of Focus

All Research

More Roads May Pave The Way To More Traffic

From interview with Professor Matt Turner

Get ready for “Carmageddon:” Los Angeles will close one of its main freeways, Interstate 405, for 53 hours, starting Friday night and running through Monday morning.

It’s part of a billion-dollar widening project that LA hopes will ease chronic traffic jams.

For decades, urban areas across the country have been adding lanes and building roads to fight congestion, but a recent study by University of Toronto researchers finds that widening and building more roads actually creates more traffic.

“What we found was that in cities where there was more roads, there was more driving,” economist Matthew Turner, a co-author of the study, tells weekends on All Things Considered host Guy Raz. “In particular, if you had 1 percent more roads, you had 1 percent more driving in those cities.”

Traffic Equations
If you increase the number of highways in a city by 1 percent, it causes driving to also increase by 1 percent.+1=0
Increasing public transit by 1 percent has no effect on traffic.
Source: The Fundamental Law of Road Congestion

Turner’s study also looked at public transportation, and the results were similar: More buses and trains create more riders, but generally don’t make a dent in traffic problems.

“As you increased a city’s stock of light rail or bus cars, that there’s no impact on the amount of driving,” Turner says.

Although that may sound surprising, he says, it’s a logically consistent with the study’s data on driving. “As you add roads to a city those roads get filled up. There are people waiting to use that capacity. The result on transit is almost exactly the opposite of that.”

Ultimately, Turner’s research has shown that the only way to deal with congestion is to follow the lead of cities like London, Singapore and Stockholm, which have adopted “congestion pricing” — tolls on people driving in the center city. Turner says Stockholm, specifically, has seen a 50 percent reduction in travel time at peak times because of tolls.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg floated such a plan for Manhattan, but it’s stalled. And that doesn’t surprise Turner.

The economist admits that it’s tough for drivers to get used to paying for something that they are used to getting for free. But but he says the extra charges will be worthwhile in the end.

“We have enough experience with these programs now to know that they really work,” Turner says. “In response to pretty small fees, you see big reductions in travel time.”

Related Content