Skip to content

About PERC

All Areas of Focus

All Research

Donate

Predators and Precedents: Grizzly Bears, Joe Pickett, and the Law of Delisting

Abstract

When a grizzly bear kills a fisherman in C.J. Box’s Three-Inch Teeth, the attack occurs in Wyoming’s Bighorn Mountains—territory where bears “weren’t supposed to be.” This fictional scenario reflects a real dilemma: grizzly bears have recovered so successfully that they now roam beyond designated recovery zones, yet federal delisting efforts have repeatedly failed, caught between contested science and competing narratives about connectivity requirements, ESA policies, federal authority, state and local control, and the prospects for coexistence with other apex predators.

This Article examines how popular culture, legal frameworks, and conservation science intersect to shape wildlife policy. Box’s novel— mixing biological accuracy with dramatic license—both reflects and amplifies the competing narratives that operate beneath explicit policy debates. These narratives about species vulnerability, federal versus state management authority, and human–wildlife conflict risk have become embedded in legal frameworks. The result is a governance system in which connectivity is both essential for conservation and a barrier to delisting, and where the challenge extends beyond managing bears to managing the cultural contexts of human–wildlife coexistence.

Read the paper. 

Written By
  • Temple Stoellinger
    • Senior Fellow

    Temple Stoellinger is a PERC senior fellow and an associate professor and Wyoming Excellence Chair at the University of Wyoming, with a dual appointment in the Haub School of Environment and Natural Resources and the College of Law.

  • Kelly Dunning
    Kelly Dunning
    • Lone Mountain Fellow
  • David Willms

    David Willms is the associate vice president for the National Wildlife Federation and the co-host of the Your Mountain podcast.

  • Arthur Middleton
    • Impact Fellow

    Arthur is an assistant professor of wildlife management and policy at the University of California – Berkeley and director of the Middleton lab. He also currently serves as a Trustee of the Buffalo Bill Center of the West and a science advisor to the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation.

  • Bethany Aragon

    Bethany Aragon is a retired U.S. Army Colonel and a second-year student in the University of Wyoming’s dual J.D./M.A. program in Environment and Natural Resources.

Date
Topics
Related Content